Why Choose Mix and Match Travel Agency

We love building custom vacations for each of our clients. Whether you want us to handle just the big details or the smaller points too, we are here to make sure you have a dream vacation. With no fees and personal service, we are equipped to plan and execute anything from a cozy Caribbean getaway, large family trips at sea, magical experiences at Walt Disney World, stunning European adventures and much, much more.  Our agency focuses on cruises, Walt Disney World, Hawaii, tropical vacations outside of the United States, Europe, Asia and other amazing international getaways.  At this time, we do not offer our services to domestic destinations like Nantucket, Yellowstone, New York City, etc. We are so excited to get started on your next trip!

  • "My husband and I have never taken a cruise and were apprehensive to do so. Shay made it so simple including reminding us to sign up for fabulous deals that others we met on the cruise did not know about. We seriously had the most wonderful time and can't wait until our next trip!" — Danielle M.
  • "OMG!!!! You really knocked it out of the park for us. It was the most restful amazing getaway. Mayaland transportation was so on top of every little detail. The resort we do not have one complaint. Well only one the fact we had to leave yesterday. Every employee we came in contact with went above any beyond so friendly and kind. We ate at every restaurant and they were all exquisite meals. Breakfast was so fresh and delish every morning. On our last night the restaurant brought my daughter an amazing dessert that was so thoughtful of them. Our rooms the view was to die for. I know I wasn’t your easiest client but I’m so used to something not being taken care of. I promise next time to trust you. Thank you again for making this trip so special for us all." — Linda L.
  • "Thanks for helping us with a fantastic vacation! It was the deep breath we needed, and the kids had a blast." — Cristen M.
  • We had a great “Framily Vacation” thanks to Mix & Match Mama Travel!  From the cruise to the parks- everything was planned for us!  It was truly a magical time!  —  Abigail C.
  • "Mix and Match Travel Agency was amazing to work with. Jane and Erika both were so incredibly knowledgeable and helpful. They were so responsive and helped us navigate our first Disney experience and truly go above and beyond. We cannot wait to book through them again. 1st class travel agency!" - Dustie D.
  • "We love Mix and Match Travel!  They are now in the process of planning our third vacation.  They are so easy to work with and really listen to your needs and wants.  Everything has always been seamless.  I highly recommend letting them plan your next get away!"
  • "Thank you so much for everything you did to make our honeymoon amazing. We had the best time and I would definitely recommend Sandals. We ate and drank our way through there and came back with some amazing memories and friends we will cherish. Overall, it was the perfect relaxing trip for a honeymoon — It was heaven!" - Elyse
  • "Erika couldn't have been easier and sweeter to work with! I was so overwhelmed by the idea of planning meals, rides, transportation at Disney-Mix and Match Travel made it a dream! They took care of everything and were so helpful in planning rides/activities that were perfect for the ages of my 3 kids. " - Ashley J.
  • “Using Mix and Match Travel was a perfect experience from start to finish. It was our first time going on a cruise, so we had no idea what to expect or how to plan. Thankfully, Erika was patient with us and helped make what my husband referred to as a "trip of a lifetime." We are already planning on using them again for an upcoming Disney World trip!” - Anna H.
  • “By far the BEST and easiest travel agency I've ever worked with! Erika and Shay did an awesome job planning our Hawaiian cruise and were always so accommodating and easy to talk with. We can't wait to plan another memorable vacation with Mix and Match Travel Agency! Thank you ladies for all you do!!” - Julie B.

About Us


Shay Shull started Mix and Match Travel Agency in June of 2012 to combine her love of travel with her love of connecting with people she meets online. As a popular blogger, cookbook author, speaker and mother of four, Shay has been featured on Fox News, Hallmark's Home and Family, The Today Show, QVC and more. She has had a passion for travel since she was a child and has had the privilege of setting foot in over 40 countries including almost 30 countries with her kids. Shay and her husband Andrew love nothing more than setting out on an adventure with their family.

As a travel agency owner, Shay includes a personal touch with each vacation she and her team produce. She created this boutique agency to be original for each traveler and not "one size fits all". Personal relationships with clients, unique itineraries, and specific trips tailored to individuals is her passion and what makes Mix and Match Travel Agency an award winning agency recognized as one of the leading travel agencies in the industry.

In her free time, Shay loves cheering on the Boston Red Sox, spending time in the kitchen with her kids, drinking an insane amount of coffee, reading great books, and loving on her dogs. mixandmatchmama.com .


Caroline is the Office Manager, wife to Ryan, and mom of three! Caroline is the fairy godmother of the business and customer service side of the agency. She works hand in hand with each agent to make sure they have all the information they need for their clients, double checks the paperwork and documentation, and is the finalizing step for each vacation. Caroline loves being the official checks and balances of the operation to ensure each vacation is amazing!


Mackenzie specializes in all things Social Media and Marketing. Married to Patrick and a mom of twin girls, Mackenzie works behind the scenes with our marketing and customer service. She works closely with each agent getting feedback from clients to create content, find promotions and deals for destinations, and ensuring that everyone who comes across Mix and Match Travel is confident that they are getting the best in the business.